Anyone on social media on monday night will see post after post about the michael collins movie which is being shown on rte one. Michael collins was a great lover as well as a fearsome. Michael collins, when compared to gandhi, can lead to fascinating discussions about the use and abuse of violence by oppressed peoples. How much of the downton abbey movie is historically. Im not sure why it doesnt work exactly, because its got a good central performance from liam neeson, an intelligent screenplay and handsome production design. Reminiscent of in the name of the father and, more recently, braveheart, michael collins played by liam neeson of schindlers list tells the story of a young man leading ireland in their fight for independence from the british.
Harry boland 27 april 1887 1 august 1922 was an irish republican politician. Reel history michael collins is 30 seconds from the truth about irish history reel history. The judy true story confirms that she never had any resemblance of a normal childhood. In terms of the personality, its more true to history than most other aspects of the movie. Hello ray, im not sure if you were asking me or someone else, but ill give my opinion. Michael collins had been involved in the easter uprising in 1916, but he played a relatively low key part. This film also demonstrates how dramatic devices distort historical accuracy. A reallife former player on what the film got right jeneane lesko, 82, was just 18 when she played for the grand rapids chicks. Though downton is not a real place the tv series and movie were filmed at highclere castle in hampshire, its struggles.
Republicans, imperialists and fictional teenage assassins fight it out in neil jordans 1996 biopic of. Nice paper, glad to hear that our history appeals to you. Michael collins is a 1996 biographical period drama film written and directed by neil jordan and starring liam neeson as michael collins, the irish patriot and. However, i do not think these factors should prevent anyone from seeing the film. Starring irishborn liam neeson, julia roberts, aidan quinn, and alan rickman, this extraordinary historical epic was directed by celebrated neil. Had jordan thought outside mass marketabilitys broad reachwhile our case study remains the second.
Mar 19, 2016 dubious in its historical accuracy, it traces collins struggle for irish independence, from the easter rising of 1916, to the rallying and organization of his fellow guerrilla warriors, to the negotiation of the controversial free state treaty that would plunge ireland into a bloody civil war and ultimately lead to his own assassination at. Was judy garlands mother the first one to provide her with pills. For audiences elsewhere in the world, the facts in michael collins will be less interesting than the characters and the myths, and on that basis neil jordans movie functions well, giving us a folk hero known throughout ireland as the big fella, who even with a price of 10,000 pounds on his head was able to bicycle through dublin. Clearly, this is a subject jordan cares about passionately, but he hasnt found a form to make us share his passion. Neil jordans film michael collins is anything to go by, it would seem that historical films are also. Delving into the mystery behind the love life of irelands. It won the golden lion at the venice film festival.
The man is a hero whose fighting tactics became a model for other 20thcentury struggles, a statesman who negotiated irelands break with england, a political martyr slain for the great cause he lived and breathed. Michael collins is a 1996 biographical period drama film written and directed by neil jordan and starring liam neeson as michael collins, the irish patriot and revolutionary who died in the irish civil war. Michael collins played a major part in irelands history after 1916. Michael collins is 30 seconds from the truth about irish. But, the movie is useful as a learning tool only if its historical distortions are explained. Rent michael collins 1996 starring liam neeson and julia roberts on dvd and bluray.
Neil jordans michael collins 1996 reconstructs the troubles in ireland from. Far from telling irish history straight,5 jordans film appropriates gen. Were sorry but jwapp doesnt work properly without javascript enabled. She did so at the request of director rupert goold. It is, in fact, the most successful irishproduced movie ever made. Historical inaccuracies like the carbomb were annoying but minor.
Michael collins plays a crucial role in the establishment of the irish free state in the 1920s, but becomes vilified by those hoping to create a completely independent irish republic. What are some good 1916michael collins related books. Michael collins was a great lover as well as a fearsome fighter. The downton abbey movies historical accuracy is perhaps most true to history as we watch mary crawley michelle dockery discuss the fate of her familys country estate. Michael collins was a politician and soldier who was a leading figure in the struggle for irish independence in the early 20th century. Students who are shown a movie in class can be assigned to research the historical accuracy of the movie as homework.
I f historical dramas are up your alley, you may be interested in michael collins. Playing with the facts in a movie like michael collins is a dangerous game. Michael collins, the man and the movie, stands tall. Accurately, collins is shown asking young men to kill for the irish. Vocal coaching and choreography helped make the movies performances as close to the true story as possible. As seen in the movie, hollywood studios like mgm encouraged her to take appetite suppressants, uppers, and downers to keep her thin and working productively. The author includes specific details of the irish patriots life, his major role in politics, his military strength, and the attacks he carried out as a member of sinn fein. It was after the uprising that collins made his mark leading to the treaty of 1921 that gave ireland dominion status within the british empire. Looked at in cooler 21stcentury air, michael collins, released this. Why michael collins and hollywood was a match made in heaven. Oct 21, 2019 the late 19th century battle over what type of currents should be used for indoor electricity becomes highstakes drama in the current war. Michael collins is a 1996 biopic about the eponymous irish revolutionary. In attention to historical accuracy, first man compares favorably to apollo 1995, ron howards wellknown film about the lunarlanding mission that failed. The movie based on a book by michael lewis tells the story of michael oher, a black nfl lineman who was adopted by a white southern family when he was a homeless teenager.
Michael collins neil jordan, 1996, us neil jordans film traces the career of irish republican hero michael collins, from the easter rising to his death in 1922. Michael collins was born on 16 october 1890 near clonakilty in county cork, the son of a farmer. He had the same energy and charm as he has in the movie, and neeson does a very good job of portraying this, it doesnt feel like he is playing a younger man once the film gets going. Why michael collins and hollywood was a match made in. Best books about michael collins irish leader 19 books. Each time a film takes its subject matter from history there will be arguments over accuracy. Theres tons of general stuff but personally i prefer books on specific areas. Now, in this second edition, collins takes account of the most important events and development of his remarkable pontificate. Best books about michael collins irish leader everything you need to know about michael collins, his life and times. How much of the downton abbey movie is historically accurate. Michael collins neil jordan, 1996, us film education. Jul 04, 2015 because of these two reasons, pathos and historical accuracy, the producers of michael collins should have started their movie with the great famine. Situated in a restored georgian house on emmet square, where collins once lived, the museum, tells the life story of collins through guided tours, interactive displays, audiovisuals and historical artefacts. The great famine took place when photography was in its extreme infancy so you couldnt do a slide show at the beginning of the movie.
But instead of incorporating this information about collins liam neeson into the story, jordan tacks on the printed michael collins ataglance biography and just plugs the movie full of the same sequence over and over again. Neil jordans flawed epic and the hoopla surrounding its release was something of a cultural event twenty. Jordans own direction keeps you interesting and invested in irish freedom every second of. Mar 25, 2015 michael collins played a major part in irelands history after 1916.
Id be wary of coogans book to be honest, the movie contains a lot of historical revisionism and down right lies. Collins was an irish revolutionary leader, politician, minister for finance, director of information, and teachta dala td for cork south in the first dail of 1919, adjutant general, director of intelligence, and director of organisation and arms. Michael collins is a former astronaut who was part of the gemini 10 and apollo 11 missions, the latter of which included the first lunar landing in history. Numerous historical inaccuracies plague the movie, including its. Jordan terrified by reaction to michael collins film. Papers office in dublin castle, but is keenly aware that the facts do not speak for themselves. Michael collins introduced readers to the pope who has grabbed the attention and the spiritual imaginations of catholics and others around the world. How true are these two characters to what you can read about them in history.
Michael collins is 30 seconds from the truth about irish history. Michael collins was one of the founders of what was eventually to become the republic of ireland and the film tells the story. With liam neeson, aidan quinn, julia roberts, ian hart. Neil jordans historical biopic of irish revolutionary michael collins, the man who led a guerrilla war against the uk, helped negotiate the creation of the irish free state, and. Neil jordan says he was terrified by the reaction to his michael collins movie updated thursday, 25 feb 2016 14. Feb 25, 2016 neil jordan says he was terrified by the reaction to his michael collins movie updated thursday, 25 feb 2016 14.
The man is a hero whose fighting tactics became a model for other 20thcentury struggles. Unless you come to michael collins with strong feelings about its hero, its. In terms of 1916 were in a golden age in terms of volume, not necessarly quality of books. Neil jordans historical biopic about michael collins, the man who fought for a free ireland in the early 20th century, has its heart in the right place, but it just doesnt work. That movie also made massive and expensive efforts to duplicate spacecraft cockpits, simulators, and launches. Michael collins house museum in clonakilty, cork is a museum dedicated to michael collins and the history of irish independence. A huge hit in ireland where the real life collins is a national hero. And, yes, even if the movie isnt accurate you still blame dev for everything. Helping was its being given the irish equivalent of a pg rating despite its highly violent content. Michael collins was an irish republican leader and guerrilla strategist. It was the film that sparked my unwavering interest in the life and times of michael collins and it will always have a special place in my movie collection and heart for that reason alone. Stunning cinematography, smoky lighting, film noir aesthetic, irish history, brutal combat, realistic recreations, and an all star cast.
Weve been getting the lowdown on this remarkable moment in history from the author who wrote the source material. Yes, at least in the way they had previously operated. Liam neeson, aidan quinn, julia roberts many of us can be forgiven a certain measure of sentimentality when it comes to this film. One senses an effort to sweeten history with the palatable goo of modern. Rent michael collins 1996 on dvd and bluray dvd netflix. Because of these two reasons, pathos and historical accuracy, the producers of michael collins should have started their movie with the great famine. Its certainly true that michael collins is not a work of history or a historical document, but is it true that its as accurate as jordan can make it. Did hollywood studios supply judy garland diet pills and speed to keep her skinny and working nonstop. Michael collins and the irish revolution because oconnor was a storyteller. It was directed by neil jordan and starred liam neeson, alan rickman, charles dance, and julia roberts set between 1916 and 1922 the story follows michael collins neeson as he builds the irish republican army into a fighting force capable of taking on the british empire, and achieving independence for ireland. The late 19th century battle over what type of currents should be used for indoor electricity becomes highstakes drama in the current war. Neil jordans historical biopic on the leader of the ira named michael collins is an absolute masterpiece of a film. Most twm learning guides for works of historical fiction contain an analysis of the accuracy of the film.
Questions 7 10 of the movie worksheet provide questions relating to the movies historical accuracy. Oct 12, 2018 in attention to historical accuracy, first man compares favorably to apollo 1995, ron howards wellknown film about the lunarlanding mission that failed. After leaving school he worked for the post office, spending nine years in london where he became. Nov 15, 2016 michael collins was a great lover as well as a fearsome fighter. Neil jordans historical biopic of irish revolutionary michael collins, the man who led a guerrilla war against the uk, helped negotiate the creation of the irish free state, and led the national army during the irish civil war. While still working within historical biography, edvard munch explodes set generic patterns by undermining spectacular diversion, closure, and the filmmakers usually unquestioned authority.
217 1302 698 1234 390 1509 1474 993 355 882 375 1034 168 1296 227 578 1541 1436 1252 216 973 1174 1271 437 386 166 74 871 1374 256 823 1059 162